

Stars: **1/2Price: $$
Genre: Southern, Soul, Cajun, Barbecue
Try: Baby Back Ribs, Pulled Pork, Red Velvet Cake
Skip: Corn on the Cob, Chocolate Souffle
Location: 342 E. 6th St. New York, NY
Mara's Homemade is a southern/cajun style place in the East Village. They offer a variety of seafood selections, including nightly specials. I head that the pecan crusted catfish is very good, as well as their specialty, Louisiana crawfish. If you aren't in the mood for seafood, they also have an Arkansas barbecue menu, complete with smoked ribs, brisket, pulled pork, and sausage. Arkansas style barbecue is a mix of Memphis and Texas styles. The meat is rubbed down with a blend of spices, and is then slow-smoked with hickory wood. You add the sauce at your table, with a choice of Arkansas style (Spicy/Tangy) or Texas style (Spicy/Sweet). I prefer the sweeter sauce, especially on the pulled pork.
I have been to Mara's Homemade twice now, and my overall feelings are mixed. The portions are definitely generous, but the quality of dishes varies. The pulled pork is excellent, very tender and juicy. The baby back ribs are also good, nice and smoky and tender. The brisket was almost there... the dry rub was nice but it wasn't quite as tender as I've had it at, say, Hill Country. The side dishes vary in quality as well. My no-mayo, tangy coleslaw was good paired with the pulled pork. The garlic mashed potatoes were served room-temperature, which did not fare well. The corn on the cob had been smoked, and lacked any real flavor. Also, they did not serve it with butter! Is this a southern-style place or not?? I have a feeling the corn pudding might be better, so perhaps if I return there I will order it. The guests seated next to us ordered the pecan crusted catfish, which seems to be a very popular dish, seafood-wise. To drink, I had the sweet tea, which is good, but extremely sweet. There was honey in it, for sure, and a lot of it.
On my first visit to Mara's, dessert was a disaster. We tried the chocolate souffle, which was recommended on the menu. When it came out, the cake was okay, if a little dry. It came with a sauce on the side. I tried it, and it tasted burnt. I tried to guess what it was... maybe a candied fruit sauce of some kind? We eventually had to call the waitress over because it just wasn't right. Mara herself ended up coming over. She told us it was her dark chocolate sauce, 100% real melted chocolate. Now, I can tell you, from eating thousands of pounds of chocolate in my life, that this was NOT good chocolate. Not even "okay" chocolate. It was burnt, and possibly very, very old. I didn't want to bring her spirits down, since the rest of the meal had been good. On my second visit, I ordered the red velvet cake, which was actually very good. The cream cheese frosting was dense and not too sweet. The cake was moist and it had cherries and pecans in it for flavor. Overall, a good slice of cake.
I'm not sure if I will return to Mara's Homemade, as the menu offerings are too varied in terms of quality. Some of the meal will be good, but some of it will be questionable. I will continue my search to find the best southern food in the city.